I was having a discussion via chat with Subal today and thought to bring it here in case anyone else wants to participate. Subal was asking questions related to GM's recent class "Bringing dignity to the Bhaktivinoda parivar."
This also leads into guru tattva as the guru is instrumental in giving a particular type of bhakti to the disciple.
Is the jiva's lila svarup fluid or fixed?I think the svarupa in the lila is fixed given that the svarupa is determined by the devotee's bhava/rasa. Is that correct? A jiva in sakhya would not be interested in madhurya, and vice-versa, both subjectively considering their own bhava to be the best.
Otherwise, before the jiva enters the lila, could sadhu-sanga influence the bhava being cultivated by the jiva, enough to change it from one rasa to another? Or would it be more of a nuanced change, say from sakhya to priya-narma sakhya?
Subal Das
What exactly determines a jiva's eternal lila svarup? Is it only by association? I remember GM saying jivas will be exposed to the appropriate association to develop their relationship with Krsna. Is the jiva's lila svarup fluid for fixed?
GM has explained the manifestation of sampradayas in the world as an expression of ways that Bhagavan wants to receive service. In this sense, our rasa could be said to be predetermined in that we will come in touch with a flavor of service through the sampradaya that graces us. In our Gaudiya sampradaya we are attracted to either a gopa or a gopi svarupa, because that is what the sampradaya offers. Association is everything, and our attraction is influenced by our association as well as lifetimes of connection to guru (Subal's point above), which Krsna may be engineering in his desire to accept service in a certain way. For example, we aren't attracted to reverential bhakti as some of the other sampradaya's offer. Here is a relevant quote from GM on FB:
In Sri Rupa's Brs. 2.5.38 he explains that the reason one develops a taste for one ideal/rasa/svarupa or another is because of association with a devotee influenced by a particular bhava in this and previous lives. Such association creates a bhakti rasa samskara/vasana, or latent impression stored in one's citta. This then gives rise to a desire for that same rasa as one engages in sadhana bhakti, and within that rasa the details of one's spiritual form and seva are a result of the will of the jiva influenced by that bhava/rasa.
Here is the relevant comment by Visvanatha Cakravarti:
"Among the various tastes such as sweet, sour and bitter, a particular
person has a particular liking because of previous impressions.
Because of impressions from past life of a particular rasa
such as däsya, in this life also, the person has that taste alone and
not others, by the mercy of a great devotee with a similar taste.
This is the case of for the two types of däsya and the other three
higher rasas."
As for the lila svarupa being fixed, yes it is eternal and unchanging, because it is a form made of a certain flavor of bhava. Madhurya, Sakhya, Vatsalya, etc. There may be secondary rasas that influence/enhance the main, but they do not overwhelm it or change it, for example a gopa being overwhelmed by madhurya bhava and becoming instead a gopi.
Before entering the lila, the jiva is cultivating a bhava-deha in sadhana that fits in a certain rasa. The bhava is sthayi - fixed. If the bhava is influenced by varied sadhu-sanga, I would say the person was in the earlier stages of bhakti and not clear what his/her bhava was. Maybe that influence of sadhu's is clearing that up as the sadhaka is practicing. But true cultivation of a sthayi bhava in middle/higher stages of sadhana will not be changed by association.